February 18, 2018

New Research: 35% of Competitive Local Keywords Have Local Pack Ads

Posted by Dr-Pete

Over the past year, you may have spotted a new kind of Google ad on a local search. It looks something like this one (on a search for “oil change” from my Pixel phone in the Chicago suburbs):

New Research: 35% of Competitive Local Keywords Have Local Pack Ads

These ads seem to appear primarily on mobile results, with some limited testing on desktop results. We’ve heard rumors about local pack ads as far back as 2016, but very few details. How prevalent are these ads, and how seriously should you be taking them?

11,000 SERPs: Quick summary

For this study, we decided to look at 110 keywords (in 11 categories) across 100 major US cities. We purposely focused on competitive keywords in large cities, assuming, based on our observations as searchers, that the prevalence rate for these ads was still pretty low. The 11 categories were as follows:

  • Apparel
  • Automotive
  • Consumer Goods
  • Finance
  • Fitness
  • Hospitality
  • Insurance
  • Legal
  • Medical
  • Services (Home)
  • Services (Other)

We purposely selected terms that were likely to have local pack results and looked for the presence of local packs and local pack ads. We collected these searches as a mobile user with a Samsung Galaxy 7 (a middle-ground choice between iOS and a “pure” Google phone).

Why 11 categories? Confession time – it was originally 10, and then I had the good sense to ask Darren Shaw about the list and realized I had completely left out insurance keywords. Thanks, Darren.

Finding #1: I was very wrong

I’ll be honest – I expected, from casual observations and the lack of chatter in the search community, that we’d see fewer than 5% of local packs with ads, and maybe even numbers in the 1% range.

Across our data set, roughly 35% of SERPs with local packs had ads.

Across industry categories, the prevalence of pack ads ranged wildly, from 10% to 64%:

New Research: 35% of Competitive Local Keywords Have Local Pack Ads

For the 110 individual keyword phrases in our study, the presence of local ads ranged from 0% to 96%. Here are the keywords with >=90% local pack ad prevalence:

  • “car insurance” (90%)
  • “auto glass shop” (91%)
  • “bankruptcy lawyer” (91%)
  • “storage” (92%)
  • “oil change” (95%)
  • “mattress sale” (95%)
  • “personal injury attorney” (96%)

There was no discernible correlation between the presence of pack ads and city size. Since our study was limited to the top 100 US cities by population, though, this may simply be due to a restricted data range.

Finding #2: One is the magic number

Every local pack with ads in our study had one and only one ad. This ad appeared in addition to regular pack listings. In our data set, 99.7% of local packs had three regular/organic listings, and the rest had two listings (which can happen with or without ads).

Finding #3: Pack ads land on Google

Despite their appearance, local packs ads are more like regular local pack results than AdWords ads, in that they’re linked directly to a local panel (a rich Google result). On my Pixel phone, the Jiffy Lube ad at the beginning of this post links to this result:

New Research: 35% of Competitive Local Keywords Have Local Pack Ads

This is not an anomaly: 100% of the 3,768 local pack ads in our study linked back to Google. This follows a long trend of local pack results linking back to Google entities, including the gradual disappearance of the “Website” link in the local pack.

Conclusion: It’s time to get serious

If you’re in a competitive local vertical, it’s time to take local pack ads seriously. Your visitors are probably seeing them more often than you realize. Currently, local pack ads are an extension of AdWords, and require you to set up location extensions.

It’s also more important than ever to get your Google My Business listing in order and make sure that all of your information is up to date. It may be frustrating to lose the direct click to your website, but a strong local business panel can drive phone calls, foot traffic, and provide valuable information to potential customers.

Like every Google change, we ultimately have to put aside whether we like or dislike it and make the tough choices. With more than one-third of local packs across the competitive keywords in our data set showing ads, it’s time to get your head out of the sand and get serious.

Sign up for The Moz Top 10, a semimonthly mailer updating you on the top ten hottest pieces of SEO news, tips, and rad links uncovered by the Moz team. Think of it as your exclusive digest of stuff you don’t have time to hunt down but want to read!

New Research: 35% of Competitive Local Keywords Have Local Pack Ads

Get Free Site Analysis
Featured Services

What our customers say…

Click On Solutions
Reviewed from Google

5 out of 5 stars

Barbara Williams
Barbara Williams

5 out of 5 stars

posted 7 months ago

Utilized Click On Solutions to help do a few plans for my logo and the work they did was first class! Was sick of procuring individuals at a mid-cost and getting alright work. At long last got an OK cost with a quality item also. I highly recommend them to everyone. They are the best in their field.

Jones Blaze
Jones Blaze

5 out of 5 stars

posted 10 months ago

I just never knew I could get in touch with so many people just by using some simple marketing tools and targeted Google keywords. The Click on Solution guys (and gals) have been a huge part of the growth that my business has been through in 2017. Being a stay-at-home mom with a creative streak, I have started sowing wedding dresses out of my home in south Florida about 4 years ago, when my first baby was born. Recently, however, I’ve been desperately hoping to increase my clientele throughout the US. I’ve read about other folks who’ve done that, and thought, what is stopping me? I am so glad I signed up for Click on Solutions, because guess what?? I even get orders from around the world now! Places like Canada, Germany and Ireland, to name a few. The best part (besides the obvious increase in revenue) is that learning about all these things, like targeted marketing and business plans, and Google AdWords, has been such a great process! Ronnie and Michelle have explained to me what they’re going to do every step of the way and helped me get on the first page (!) on Google, and it really just tightened my marketing to target those women that want a unique wedding dress made by yours truly! So fun and so cool, I am thoroughly thankful to you guys, and I already told Paul there—when he finally proposes to his girlfriend, I’d like first dibs on designing a one-of-a-kind wedding dress for her! Thank you again, guys!

Anthony Varela
Anthony Varela

5 out of 5 stars

posted 7 months ago

Strong innovative shop with an introduction to the business comes about. Presented by an outsider since we were searching for an imaginative asset to help create sites and versatile applications for our customers; comes about have been solid, on the spending plan and on time. The solid support of the group and its administration ethics. I would definitely recommend them to everyone who need Advertising solutions.

Richardo Rafile
Richardo Rafile

5 out of 5 stars

posted 7 months ago

As a customer of Click On Solutions, I need to impart my positive experience to their very expert laborers. We came in contact couple of months back and just in a matter of around 8 to 9 months my site has picked up features, this is all a direct result of the internet advertising procedure these individuals utilize. I highly recommend them to everyone for online advertising needs.

Jillian Morrison
Jillian Morrison

5 out of 5 stars

posted 10 months ago

A lot of the stuff that they were able to help me with were things that I was familiar with BUT they kind basically showed me how my knowledge looks like on steroids, so to speak. So although I'm quite savvy about all these things marketing your website and expanding your clientele through social media, I was still able to make such an amazing use of what this team had to offer! — I got so much more clients and expanded my business through their marketing strategies, that I literally had to hire an assistant. As a by-the-way, I’ve always been envious of people who have personal assistants, and I had always wanted to join that elite group. And now I did, and I wholly feel that it’s thanks to Click on Solutions.